A pill to stop your periods, scream the headlines announcing the fact that scientists are working on a pill that could eliminate the need for women to have monthly menstruation.

Yes, it might be beneficial for sensitive women like me, who suffer from painful periods and PMS for a few days every month. But, despite my discomfort, I’d rather bear the pain (I can’t take painkillers), leave my daughter with my parents, and catch up on my rest on those days, than pop a pill to get rid of a perfectly normal biological function.

My period and my monthly changes define my womanhood, and no one has the right to play around with that. Besides, who decides these things anyway? And who benefits by defining a woman’s period as something that should be done away with? Only the kind of men who have no respect for women and believe that a woman’s period is a mere inconvenience.

Men like Dr. Elsimar Coutinho, a Brazilian gynecologist and co-author of the book “Is Menstruation Obsolete?” (I wonder what gave him THAT idea!), who writes,

From a medical point of view, menstruation has no beneficial effects for anyone. For many women, it is actually harmful to their health.

I have never read a bigger load of CRAP!!! (And I never use three exclamation marks, so you can imagine how MAD I am).

Would Mother Nature design something so vital to our fertility, and then go make it “harmful”? I think not! Besides what gives a clueless male like Dr. Coutinho, the right to tell a woman that she should deny her femininity?

I love being a woman and I support every woman’s right to control her own body, even if she chooses to do so by having fewer periods. But it should be HER choice - not the result of brainwashing by males, who understand nothing of what a woman goes through during her monthly cycle.

I mean how would men feel if we decided that it was inconvenient and unattractive for them to have body and facial hair, and that they needed a pill or injection to “eliminate” these unnecessary vestiges of manhood?

And while we’re on that route, why not just declare testosterone a threat to World Peace, since it’s the cause of most of the violence we see in the world today? Lets have a pill to do away with testosterone.

Voluntary Emasculation In The Name Of Non-Violence!!! I wonder how that would sound to men like Dr. Coutinho.

I’m no feminist, just a woman who loves being a woman (and everything that goes with it). But, when I see such blatant and arrogant attempts by male doctors to control a woman’s body, I really wish I were!

Like women of ancient times, I see my cycle as a time for rest and renewal. A time to nurture myself and enjoy my womanhood. “Our monthly bleeding is the source of life. Why then are we so ashamed of it?”, writes Felicity Artemis Flowers in her article titled The P.M.S. Conspiracy, where she describes how patriarchy has made women feel ashamed of this vital, beautiful, and life-renewing bodily function.

In this uplifting piece, she writes

Ancient people called menstrual blood ‘Wise Blood’. The ancients recognized the awesome wisdom and power of the menstrual cycle and it was honored as a source of spiritual enlightenment. The forgetting of this essential wisdom, and the distress that this has caused the psyche of womankind is a consequence of the total betrayal of women by the patriarchy.

In ancient times a woman’s bleeding was her time to retreat to a special place where she would be attended, bathed and nurtured by other women. It was honored as her time to tune in to the transformation happening within her, to turn inward, to get closer to her Self, to listen to and hear her Self.

On her menstrual retreat a woman secluded herself to give herself to her bleeding. With each lunation she could immerse herself in the realm of the unconscious and focus her energy into her expanded psychic connection to All Life. She would then return with offerings of insight and visions for the community. She was a priestess, a shamanness. Her bleeding was thus honored as her Gift.

In her article, she also gives women some great tips to honor themselves and embrace menstrual reality.

On the role of patriarchy in creating a disconnect between women and womanhood, Felicity writes,

The ultimate message of the male-supremecist culture to all daughters, well before their first bleeding, is that proof of your worth as a woman lies in how successfully you pretend that nothing significant is happening while you are bleeding: how well you can contain it, act emotionally neutral, not retain water, be a good robot in the workplace; how well you deny your true nature in pretending you don’t want to lie down and rest, take a warm bath, or walk through a flower garden. You must be efficient and “take it like a man”, take pills so you won’t feel it, take diuretics so its ’show’. Don’t let anyone know. Pretend you’re not bleeding.

As we presently exist within patriarchally defined reality, our body’s cyclic imitation of the moon’s waxing to fullness is called “bloat”, a symptom, a malady. This misnaming of Life’s expression of itself is a total reversal from the perception of the female body as sacred.

Words are powerful in conveying and perpetuating attitudes, and patriarchal words such as “bloat”, “discharge”, ‘unclean’ and ‘P.M.S.’ are effective in Propagating Menstrual Shame. They describe the deliberate destruction of female consciousness by keeping her from perceiving her divinity.

In India, this time of rest simply required that a woman was allowed to take a break from her household chores. Over the ages it was perversely twisted and given an “unclean” tag to prohibit a woman from entering the kitchen or a place of worship, a practice that is still followed today, in conservative communities.

We all go through a point in our lives when we have a “love-hate” relationship with our period, especially the women who experience a lot of pain and discomfort. I went through that in my teens, when I was uncomfortable with my feminine self (my mother) and identified more with the masculine (my father).

As I learned to love, appreciate and enjoy my femininity, I came to accept my cycle as perfectly normal, and to view it as a period of cleansing and renewal. I enjoy retreating for a couple of days to catch up on some much-needed rest, take a break from work, catch up on my reading, listen to music, even watch some TV.

Whether women choose to use pills to have fewer periods is a personal choice, made for personal reasons. But, to allow anyone to convince me that my periods are unnecessary, is to deny being a woman. And that’s completely unacceptable to me.

Recommended Reading:

Thanks to Mind-Mart, I came across this book by Dr. Susan Rako that dispels the notions being promoted by corporate medicine in America.

No More Periods?: The Risks of Menstrual Suppression and Other Cutting-Edge Issues About Hormones and Women’s Health

Observing the radical shift in the medical community toward menstrual suppression as a viable option in women’s health, Dr. Rako sees not only a vast information gap for women, but a serious health crisis on the horizon. Drug companies and many health professionals are promoting the idea that it is okay, even preferable, for women to forgo their periods if they are not trying to get pregnant, and many women, when faced with the choice, are seriously considering that option. But what isn’t being discussed enough are the hazards of such suppression, risks that include osteoporosis, heart attacks, strokes, and cancer.

In No More Periods? Dr. Rako delves into the whys, hows, and musts of women’s gynecological health and takes a reasoned stand for believing that nature and our bodies have an intelligence about this critical issue. This book is a call to sanity from a woman who has become known as a devout defender of women’s health rights.

“Tampering with the hormonal climate of healthy menstruating women, including teenage girls whose lives stretch ahead for decades, for the purpose of doing away with their periods is, in a word, reckless. Manipulating women’s hormonal chemistry for the purpose of menstrual suppression threatens to be the largest uncontrolled experiment in the history of medical science. Hands down.

What the media has not conveyed, what the public has not heard, what too few health professionals know, and what every woman and her doctor must know about the hazards of menstrual suppression deserves a voice. I am determined that it will have one.”€Susan Rako, M.D.

Popularity: 47% [?]

10 Comments

  1. Mind Mart said,

    July 19th, 2007, 3:58 am

    Menstrual Cessation…

    Why would anyone want to have a period if that means heavy bleeding, clotting, and pain every month for 30 years? Well, menstruation and painful periods are two different subjects, but marketing is targeting menstruation as a problem in general.
    A few …

  2. Mind Mart said,

    July 19th, 2007, 4:02 am

    Patriarchy or mysoginism?

  3. Sorab Dalal said,

    July 23rd, 2007, 5:44 pm

    I could not agree more. Menstruation is a natural part of the cycle and while it can be painful for some women, I don’t think it is clear what the long term effects of getting rid of a menstrual cycle could be. I am a scientist and I think that sometimes some of my colleagues tend to overstate their case especially when it is something that is a potential money maker
    Good article, keep it up

  4. Priya Florence Shah said,

    July 24th, 2007, 6:25 am

    Thanks for your comments, people.

  5. Suman said,

    August 3rd, 2007, 8:28 am

    I disagree with the view that one would be tampering with Nature or women’s feminity in altering this aspect of a woman’s health! If Science can alter the way a woman becomes a mother why not do away with something when you dont need it? I am sure methods to alter periods would be used only after they are proven to be safe! Imagine, not having to count days and think about dates before planning for things like travel etc! Feminity doesnt lie in going thru pain every month!

  6. FemmePhilosopher said,

    August 6th, 2007, 8:07 am

    I can’t believe what I am reading! Your opinion is obviously not considering women who suffer real pain from their menstrual cycle. I don’t mean simply just PMS or a slight case of the cramps, I suffer from a endometriosis, a condition that causes me great amounts of pain, not only through my menstrual cycle but for weeks after, resulting in almost constant extreme period pain. This pill to stop periods is empowering for me, I can improve my quality of life. There are many women who feel the same, and it has nothing to do with men. My options are endure terrible and unbearable pain, have a hysterectomy or take this pill so I can take control over my life again.
    It’s an actual fact that women have more menstrual cycles in modern times than we are supposed too. In ancient times women on average had more children, meaning they had fewer menstrual cycles and so that ‘time to retreat to a special place where she would be attended, bathed and nurtured by other women’ was not very often and certainly not as wonderful as it might sound today. Another fact is that birth control has always been controlled by men, up until only very recently, the last 40 years, have women been able to choose contraceptives, it was patriarchy that stopped women making that choice for themselves and it will be misinformed women such as yourself who discourage women from making that decision today.

  7. Priya Florence Shah said,

    August 6th, 2007, 7:55 pm

    Oh I DO consider women who have pain - I’ve suffered from it since my teens. It lays me low for days.

    But, I have worked in the field of science and, like Sorab here, I question the wisdom of scientists and those who choose to treat a women’s natural biological functions like a disease, and in so doing, condemn future generations of women to believing that menstruation is unnecessary and should be eliminated from the human experience.

    That research money, in my opinion, could have been spent on researching nutritional or natural ways to alleviate the symptoms of these disorders. Eliminating menstruation is not a rational way to go about it because of the sociological and psychological implications in younger women.

    As a scientist, and a healer, I have learned that just because something CAN be done does not mean it SHOULD be done. It’s time that scientists and medical professionals considered the social and psychological implications of their actions.

  8. fred said,

    October 24th, 2007, 3:43 am

    and yet you’ll contracept…poisoning your fertility…

  9. Harish said,

    November 17th, 2007, 6:42 pm

    Hey, the doctor just wanted to help out some women who wanted relief from any inconvenience caused due to periods..I wonder why you have to tar all men with your big black brush for that..seems you really dislike men..’testosterone causes violence’. Interesting! You forgot that very often (in fact more often than it causes violence..much more often), testosterone also builds skyscrapers, ships and puts people on the moon (I’m scared to say ‘men on the moon’)! Take a chill pill instead of reading sinister designs of ‘male doctors wanting to control women’s bodies’ where none exist.

  10. All Seasons Health said,

    January 7th, 2008, 7:21 pm

    REDUCING PRE-MENSTRUAL SYNDROME (PMS)
    Once a month, millions of women experience the unpleasant and disruptive effects of their hormonal cycles. Studies show women with more severe PMS have unusually low levels of certain nutrients, so many health experts urge a nutritional approach.
    Three key factors increase the severity of PMS - poor nutrition, lack of exercise and stress. By improving the quality of foods, eating less of certain foods, exercising regularly, and learning to reduce stress, women can feel better all month.
    Five steps can reduce the severity of PMS. Results are cumulative. Many of these recommendations are the same as those in the program for weight control and lowering cholesterol.
    Enjoy fresh, natural foods.
    Eat more fresh fish and poultry, whole grains, nuts, fresh fruits, vegetables. Drink plenty of water, herb teas and fruit juices. Prepare food simply, using a
    Avoid certain foods and drugs.
    Cut down or avoid salt, sugar, white flour, convenience foods full of chemicals, dairy products and red meat, chocolate, soft drinks and coffee. Studies show women with PMS consume more of these foods than women who do not. Cigarettes and coffee can deplete your body of nutrients and aggravate PMS.
    Supplement with key vitamins and minerals.
    Many clinics recommend foods or supplements rich in B-complex, magnesium, zinc, beta carotene, GLA and other vitamins, minerals and herbs. By containing many of these nutrients, Spirulina is useful in a PMS reducing plan, and several PMS supplements contain Spirulina.
    Exercise.
    Vigorous activity will increase your blood flow, oxygenate tissues, and help lift depression and anxiety.
    Discover the art of relaxation.
    Stress makes PMS worse. Create a more relaxing environment. Learn to let go through muscle relaxation, talking to friends, or meditation.

Leave a Comment

This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots. (see: www.captcha.net)

Please enter the text to verify your comment. It should only contain the numbers 0-9 and the lettes A-F.

The image is hard to read. Generate a

eXTReMe Tracker